Gimme Five: Turning a 50-State Challenge into a Wisconsin Adventure

Gimme Five at the Wisconsin State Capitol. Photo: Jeanine Marie
Gimme Five at the Wisconsin State Capitol. Photo: Jeanine Marie

The Origins of Gimme Five

Before Gimme Five became a hit, the creators behind it started off as every other person: kids imagining what they wanted to be when they were older. In New Jersey, their friendship and creative adventures started. Little did they know, they had just planted the seeds for their future creative business.

“We started doing theater and sports in middle school and liked a lot of different things together. Then I moved to Germany. We were separated for a long time.” said Eli, “We reconnected about three years ago with the notion that we had some unfinished business. We wanted to make something creatively together.”

Originally, Gimme Five was made with the intent of being a podcast. Still separated with Eli being in England, the podcast was used so they could have five minutes to talk about anything that was on their minds that day. It brought both closer than ever, even though there were thousands of miles between them.

“It’s never truly work when you’re having fun and when those creative juices are flowing. You’re working with not just a business partner but a brother.” said Jones.

From a podcast, it changed into mostly short-form video content on apps like TikTok and Instagram. Whether its pulling cards, playing games or going to their new favorite state, they are dedicated to making something entertaining for people to watch.

“We always put time in and prioritized it, and slowly, it started to gain ground. Our first big thing was Life Madness back in 2024, which is a spinoff that we run of March Madness. From there we did sketch stuff, and now have done this series.” said Eli.

How They Found Their New Favorite State

In September, the duo decided they wanted to find their favorite state in America. From that, the viral Favorite State Challenge series was born.

“Everybody has an allegiance to a state, how can we make this fun,” said Eli.

This idea of this series was divided into three parts, first with eliminating states. With a cauldron in hand, they would select states and eliminate them in different ways each day. Once they had a winner, the second part was to travel and experience the state. Finally, a challenge in the winning state had to be completed. All of this would be filmed and posted.

“If we come up with a specific challenge for each state, what are 50 things varying degrees of difficulty? Like Nebraska, we would have had to buy a house, which would have been impossible,” said Eli.

Wisconsin beat Nevada in the final. Instead of officiating a Las Vegas wedding, they were tasked with eating and drinking a total of 25 pounds of cheese, beer and bratwurst. Each state had their own unique challenge that were designed by Eli and Jones.

“It was surfing in Hawaii. I’ve surfed in New Jersey and gotten destroyed, so I can’t imagine what would happen in Hawaii. Another one that stands out to me is Tennessee. We were supposed to get a song on Nashville Country Radio while competing with Morgan Wallen,” said Jones, “I think it worked out perfectly. We ended up getting some more achievable challenges towards the final three states.”

Wisconsin Welcomes Gimme Five

Once in Wisconsin, the guys had plenty to explore for the first time. With a possible World Series win around the corner, Eli and Jones attended the NLCS clinching watch party inside American Family Field.

“The passion we saw, especially coming from New York, where we have amazing fans, to see a team that hasn’t been to a World Series in 40 years; to be there in the moment when they clinched, it’s a feeling you can’t even put it in words,” said Eli.

They also attended the Cowboys vs. Packers game at Lambeau Field for Sunday Night Football.

“Green Bay was wild. We met a bunch of cool Packer fans. Met some Cowboy fans, unfortunately. We have MetLife Stadium in Jersey, and it’s one big parking lot in the middle of the Meadowlands,” said Jones, “Nothing that exciting. There are some tailgates but nothing like Titletown. They do it differently.”

Along with a sports filled trip, they also got to experience all the major cities, including Madison where they stayed. They toured the capital, enjoyed time with one of their friends who lives locally and completed the challenge by going to bars around the capital. Outside of the physical locations, the people of Wisconsin also left impression.

“It’s true what they say about that Midwestern charm. I am from New York and New Jersey. We’re used to a little bit of a shorter attitude towards strangers, and we were welcomed with open arms,” said Jones.

Wisconsin Is Under Review…

Gimme Five gave the state an 11/10 and kept describing their experience as incredible. They stated that they are for sure coming back in the future to visit but are going to focus on tackling places that aren’t in the major cities, visiting places not checked off the bucket list the first time.

“We started this trip saying, alright, we have to do this for a video. We ended saying, I wish we didn’t need to be filming right now. Let’s just go do things,” said Eli.

The Goal and What’s Coming Next

As exciting as filming and exploring new things is, every creator has a goal in mind for their piece of work. Whether it’s a view count goal or a message they want their fans to understand, most videos are created with a reason behind them.

“I hope if anything people can take from the series, I hope they follow us, but I hope they also say Wisconsin looks sick and I want to go to Wisconsin,” said Eli, “To be able to put a spotlight on this state while it’s having this incredible sports moment right now, to give people a lens into everyday life in Wisconsin and the cool things it has to offer was super cool. I hope that our non-Wisconsin viewers and international viewers can take that with them as a lesson from the series.”

Although their series is over, people can catch them on all social media platforms trying to trade a paper clip for different items until they can buy a racehorse and then race it. Imagination is the start to a unique creation, and no one knows that better than Gimme Five.

Check out Gimme Five here: @gimmefivetv